Colored Mascara: Fun or Freakish?

Sometimes, some people come to the conclusion that a full set of black or dark brown eyelashes simply doesn't pack enough style power. There needs to be something more, something bolder, something turquoise, red or fuchsia.
Imagine how Gone with the Wind might have gone had Scarlet O'Hara accessorized her famous green curtain dress with green eyelashes. How would Elizabeth Taylor's famous violet eyes pop when surrounded by electric blue? Should Pink use colored mascara to paint her eyelashes her namesake shade?
There isn't a whole lot of middle room when it comes to colored mascara - people either like it or hate it and they don't tend to hold back on their opinions on either side. If you're thinking about giving that funky-colored mascara brush a twirl, consider the two camps of thought.
Fun: Eclectic Impact
Eyes, windows, soul. When you meet someone for the first time, what do you first check out? Their eyes. When a person is really smiling, how can you tell? Their eyes. Your peepers convey information about who you are, how you are and what you are.
Proponents for colored mascara believe that people should not be limited to basic black or brown? If you're feeling pink, rock pink eyelashes so everyone knows how peppy you are feeling. If you want to creatively draw attention to the fact that you've finally found the perfect blue shirt, wear blue mascara to match. The whole point of cosmetics is to put your best you forward - if your best you happens to be eclectic and confident enough to pull off bold mascara, do it. After all, boldly hued hair is accepted, so why should eyelashes be any different?
Freakish: Too Much
If you want to do something bold with your eyes, why not enjoy the benefits of brightly hued eyeliner or eyeshadow? Colored mascara takes it a step too far, opponents say.
The surprise that comes with seeing someone wearing colored mascara often detracts from the overall look that the wearer is attempting to convey. Yes, colored mascara will make a statement, but it's a singular statement about the person's lashes, not the person's sense of style. The unexpected look is often described as alien in appearance - which might not necessarily be what you're going for.
Given that mascara is intended to showcase your eyes, the use of bold colored mascara fails in that endeavor, instead taking the attention away from the color of your baby blues, browns, greens or hazels.
Is Compromise Possible?
If you want to test out the funky vibe of colored mascara without making people stare during your morning commute, compromise can be found. If you've been eyeing electric blue mascara, test drive a dark navy shade. If you're interested in red, try a dark cinnamon first and work your way bold. That way, people will be staring, but to try to figure out why you look so much more interesting than everyone around you.